Witchblade #139 – Review
By Ron Marz (writer), Michael Gaydos (guest artist), Troy Peteri (letters)
The Story: After the exceptionally traumatic events of the last few issues, Sara is ordered to see her Department’s psychiatrist. Following the appointment, she makes a trip to the cemetery to visit her sister’s grave, but runs into the master of the Darkness in the process.
What’s Good: As much as I absolutely loved last month’s one shot, it felt rather ill-timed and I’m very glad the focus is back where it belongs—on Sara’s quest to find and recover her daughter. Or at least her attempts to deal with the emotional and psychological fallout from the event.
Ordinarily the lack of actual action and plot progression in this issue would bother me, but Marz does such a fantastic job with the characterization, and his dialog sounds so real and is so moving, that keeping the action part of this story (at least temporarily) confined to the Artifacts title doesn’t do either book any harm. I’m not sure how long my patience will hold out on that front, but as long as Marz keeps his writing at this level, and as long as Artifacts continues to deliver solid plot progression, I don’t think I’ll have much to complain about.
I have to give special props to Michael Gaydos. I was extremely disappointed when I heard this issue would be drawn by a guest artist–especially after Stjepan Sejic’s bravura outing on #138—but Gaydos knocks this one out of the park. While his art is nothing like the hyper detailed, cover-worthy panels that are Sejic’s signature, Gaydos’ rough but expressive pencils and colors are perfect for this story. (His full page splash of Ground Zero in New York is one of the most beautiful and haunting renditions of that famous image I’ve seen.
What’s Not So Good: This is a nearly impeccable issue. If were to single out anything, it would be Sara’s rather odd desecration of Kenneth Irons’ tomb. It’s not a gratuitous scene, nor is it terribly out of character, but the transition from Sara mourning at her sister’s grave, to her tearing apart a mausoleum feels forced and awkward. I understand that pages and panels are limited, but spending a little extra time on that tone shift would have made things a bit smoother.
Conclusion: Can I just say how much I love Witchblade lately, and Top Cow’s direction in general? Compelling storytelling, beautiful artwork and dynamic characters make this a series not to be missed.
Grade: A
-SoldierHawk
Filed under: Image Comics, Top Cow Tagged: | Witchblade, Ron Marz, Michael Gaydos, Comic Book Reviews, Weekly Comic Book Review, Troy Peteri, Witchblade #139 review, Witchblade #139New Avengers #6 – Review
by Brian Michael Bendis (writer), Stuart Immonen (pencils), Wade von Grawbadger (inks), Laura Martin & Rain Beredo (colors), and Chris Eliopoulos (letters)
The Story: A mystically roided up Wolverine takes on Agamotto for the fate of the universe.
What’s Good: This arc has bothered in a way; Bendis seems so intent on convincing us of the scale and stakes of this conflict but, perhaps due to the facelessness of the bad guys, I never quite bought into it. Last month’s issue promised a mystic battle of epic proportions, yet again, but this time, we get an issue that truly delivers on that. New Avengers #6 is just as big in scope and action as it promises to be.
The duel between Wolverine and Agamotto is well done, with Agamotto taking on various forms from the Marvel Universe and Wolverine’s past. It feels explosive and, well, powerful and in that sense, it does what it’s meant to. What really helps out the duel, however, is how Bendis emphasizes the Avengers team and keeps it from being just “Wolverine vs. Agamotto.” By watching the battle, showing concern, and giving support, the battle with Agamotto instead feels like a team effort by friends and, as such, it becomes a lot easier to root for Wolverine and emotionally invest in the battle itself. It’s one of those situations where Bendis is really able to highlight the chemistry this team has.
The conclusion of the conflict will no doubt be a source of some controversy, but the event itself is well done. Bendis delivers on his promise of a major character death and, all told, it’s done in good taste. The character goes out in truly heroic fashion and it feels appropriately important and massive in scale. Better still, it leaves behind a new and very compelling villain. It also leads to an excellent final page where Daimon Hellstrom wonderfully sums up who the New Avengers are and what makes them unique as a team.
The real star this month, however, is Stuart Immonen. His action scenes are as exciting as ever and his characters are, as always, very likable. What’s really awesome though is how he alters his style when depicting Wolverine’s duel, which is rendered in a really awesome, almost painted feel.
What’s Not So Good: Yeah, that character death. As I say, the event itself is a blast to read and it’s all very tastefully done, but it’s hard not to be miffed at just who gets killed.
I’ll try my best not to give it away, but it’s a character that had so much potential. Worse still, Marvel, Bendis in particular, ironically enough, have done so much to build the character up over the last year or so that killing the character off now seems almost like a betrayal. Perhaps this will be a short absence for the Avenger, which would admittedly be a bit more acceptable, but right now, it feels as though Marvel didn’t know what to do with the guy/girl, so just pushed him/her off the table.
I also found Ben’s dialogue to be a little off this month. Ben has a very distinctive voice, so much so that Bendis can’t get away with having him say throwaway lines that sound exactly like any other character. He may be able to get away with that now and then with some of the other Avengers, but not Ben.
Conclusion: Mixed feelings about that death aside, this is a fun issue that provides a strong finish to an at times uneven arc.
Grade: B
-Alex Evans
Filed under: Marvel Comics, Reviews Tagged: | Spider-Man, Marvel Comics, Iron Fist, Danny Rand, Avengers, Fantastic Four, Brian Bendis, Stuart Immonen, New Avengers, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Wolverine, Ms. Marvel, Peter Parker, The Thing, Brian Michael Bendis, Mockingbird, Comic Book Reviews, Marvel Universe, Dr. Strange, Weekly Comic Book Review, comic reviews, Ben Grimm, Alex Evans, Victoria Hand, Eye of Agamotto, Dr. Voodoo, Heroic Age, Bobbi Morse, Daimon Hellstrom, Marvel mystic, Avengers Mansion, Agamotto, New Avengers #6, New Avengers #6 reviewCatch Up on Spider-Man Just in Time for 'Big Time' [Spoilers]
"Big Time" is a brand new jumping on point, so after the jump, we've got the lowdown on the characters you need to know about to hop in feet first.
PETER PARKER
MARY JANE WATSON
NORMAN & HARRY OSBORN
Harry Osborn, Parker's best friend, is also not currently a going concern. He recently found out that he's the proud papa of a new little baby, and he's determined to raise the kid right. He screwed up huge with Normie, his other son, and rather than continue the Osborn family streak of terrible attempts at fatherhood, he's trying to turn everything around. He's never too far away from a hard turn into classic Osborn family problem solving, as he proved with a butt-kicking when Vin Gonzales made the mistake of threatening him at his own party.
AUNT MAY
CARLIE COOPER
VIN & MICHELE GONZALES
Vin is another story. He's fresh out of jail after serving some time for cheating on his duties as a cop, and no other cop wants anything to do with a snitch. That's good, though, because it's clear that Vin's time in jail changed him. He's sporting a brand new Green Goblin tattoo, and that means nothing good. His aforementioned threat to Harry Osborn still resulted in him getting his butt thoroughly kicked, though, so he clearly didn't learn how to fight in prison.
DOCTOR OCTOPUS
RHINO
THE LIZARD
Add a comment
Friday 12 NovemberBy Chris JonesNeutralThanks for doing this. I picked up Big Time and couldn't make heads or tails of a lot of it, but this definitely helps. Now my only question is, who was that weird guy in the mailroom that I apparently have to read "Green Goblin" #1-13 to know about?
ReplyFriday 12 NovemberBy The Amazing Justin Palm!NeutralThat was Phil Urich, Ben Urich's nephew, who went around as the fourth, good guy Green Goblin for a few years in the 90's. Right around then Norman came back from the dead, and that was about the end of his career in comics until now.
Friday 12 NovemberBy Zachary LachenbruchNeutralHe also appeared in the 2nd volume of Runaways. He was the co-founder of the Former Teen Hero Support Group.
Friday 12 NovemberBy Chris JonesNeutralOkay yeah, wow, I would never have picked up on that from the comic. Thanks for clarifying!
ReplyPage 1 of 1 Add your commentsNew UsersComicsAlliance Log-InAOL/AIM ScreennameDon't just sit there, start talking (well, typing).When you enter your name and e-mail address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. (We admit it's annoying. Get over it.) If you use the password at the bottom of that e-mail, you won't get any more confirmation requests from us.If you have a password (or an AOL/AIM screenname), log in under the other tabs.Name:
E-mail:
If you already have an ComicsAlliance log-in, enter it and your password.E-mail:
Password:
If you have an AOL or AIM screenname, you can use it to add a comment.Your comments:Remember meE-Mail me when someone replies to this commentFollow UsContact UsRSSFacebookTwitterRelated Articles
The History of Ant-Man Explained
The bizarro history of Hank Pym explained in one comic
Hostess Superhero
Snacks
Cosplay
The Bible
The Vault
A countdown of the most valuable comics in history.
MEET THE EDITORS Laura Hudson Chris Murphy Chris Sims Caleb Goellner David Brothers Josh WiglerSee All EditorsTag CloudBatman Wolverine Spider-Man halloween NewYorkComicCon AskChris WonderWoman Sony TheWalkingDead DcUniverseOnline GreenLantern GrantMorrison Smallville superman IronMan
Best Blogs On... ComicsBam KapowThe BeatBeaucoup KevinBully Comic Book ResourcesComics ComicsComics CurmudgeonThe Comics ReporterComics Worth ReadingThe Cool Kids TableThe Daily Cross HatchDC Universe: The SourceThe Factual OpinionGamma SquadGraphic Novel ReporterComicsICv2iFanboyInvincible Super-Blogio9JournalistaMTV's Splash PageNewsaramaRobot 6The Savage CriticsSuper PunchTechlandTopless RobotentertainmentAdult SwimAOL Radio BlogThe A.V. CLubBest Week EverBoing BoingThe BoomboxCinematicalEngadgetEntertainment WeeklyMoviefoneGizmodoRotten TomatoesTelevision Without PityTV SquadUrlesqueLifestyleAsylumComplexDIYLifeGuyismLemondropPublishersMarvel ComicsDC ComicsBoom! StudiosDark Horse ComicsDiamond DistributorsDrawn & QuarterlyDynamite EntertainmentFantagraphicsFirst SecondIDWImage ComicsNBM Graphic NovelsOni PressSlave Labor GraphicsTokyopopTop ShelfVertical, Inc.VizWebcomicsAchewoodAct-i-vateAlien Loves PredatorAmazingSuperPowersAmerican ElfAnders Loves MariaAxe CopCyanide & HappinessDark Horse PresentsDiesel SweetiesDinosaur ComicsDr. McNinjaFreak AngelsHyperbole and a HalfKate Beaton Let's Be Friends Again Maakies Nedroid Picture DiaryOvercompensatingPenny ArcadePerry Bible Fellowship Pictures for Sad Children Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal Questionable Content Top Shelf 2.0xkcd Wondermark creatorsJason AaronBrian Michael BendisEd BrubakerEddie CampbellJohn CassadayColleen CooverPeter DavidWarren EllisMatt FractionNeil GaimanScott McCloudMark MillarGrant MorrisonBryan Lee O'MalleyJeff ParkerPaul PopePeriscope StudioJeff SmithBrian K. VaughanBrian Wood Also on AOL ComicsAllianceComicsAllianceComicsAlliance is where comic books and pop culture collide, superheroes battle through movies and video games, and graphic novels steal the headlines.For the latest news on Marvel Comics, DC Comics, comic downloads, comic book movies, digital comics, free comics, and comic book movies, check out Comicsalliance.com.
ComicsAlliance Categories Anime Capes and Tights Conventions Crossover Dark Horse DC Galleries Gaming Humor Image Indie Interviews Manga Marvel Movies Music Previews Reviews Television Toys Video Webcomics WTF More on AOL: TMZ Movies Music Free Online Games PopEater Television Money Engadget Autoblog Joystiq BloggingStocks Styledash Cinematical TVSquad Fantasy Football Black VoicesComicsAlliance © Copyright 2009 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.
By using ComicsAlliance, you indicate that you have read,
understood and agreed to AOL ComicsAlliance's Terms of Service. AOLNews
Site Map | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Trademarks
© 2009 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(function($){ $.facebookSocial({options: {appId:142505772450724}});$("[name='aol-facebook-like']").facebookSocial();})(jQuery);\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Comic News And Reviews\Marvel\status.gif)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(93)
-
▼
11/14 - 11/21
(9)
- Witchblade #139 – Review
- New Avengers #6 – Review
- Catch Up on Spider-Man Just in Time for 'Big Time'...
- American Vampire #8 – Review
- What's the Meaning of DC's 'Doomsday Will Reign' T...
- Jerry Robinson Auctioning Original DC Cover Art fr...
- The First Footage of the Green Lantern Movie Is He...
- T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents #1 – Review
- Six Starlettes Up for Lady Friend and Lady Foe Rol...
- ► 11/07 - 11/14 (84)
-
▼
11/14 - 11/21
(9)